Emergentie

Emergence

6 EC

Semester 2, periode 4, 5

5021EMER6Y

Eigenaar Bachelor Bèta-gamma
Coördinator dr. J. Armas
Onderdeel van Bachelor Bèta-gamma, jaar 1Bachelor Natuur- en Sterrenkunde (joint degree), jaar 2

Studiewijzer 2021/2022

Globale inhoud

Emergence - the idea that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts - originally appeared within the context of philosophy of mind where consciousness was thought as a radical phenomenon, whereby the collection of billions of neurons gave rise to novel properties not contained in those of individual neurons. However, since the early 20th century philosophers and scientists alike have perfected and refined the concept of emergence as it was understood that emergent phenomena are ubiquitous in nature, spanning very small scales such as the world of particles or bacteria, to larger scales such as those pertinent to collective human behaviour, urban cities, and even to the scales involved in the most violent events in the universe.  

This course will discuss the history and philosophy of emergence and the attempts from both philosophers and scientists to constantly perfect its definition by means of examples. It will then discuss how different emergent phenomena in social, life and natural sciences can be understood using the same underlying principles and modelling. It will in particular introduce basic concepts and tools in mathematics, physics and programming that allow to visualise and understand interesting cases of emergence such as polarisation in magnets, crowds, opinion as well as epidemic spreading, predator/prey models and information cascades.

The course is divided into 3 parts: (1) philosophy of emergence, (2) statistical physics approach and (2) emergence in social contexts. 

Studiemateriaal

Literatuur

  • All relevant literature will be available on Canvas on a weekly basis. It consists of essays by scientists and philosophers, including P. W. Anderson, Hodgson,  Nagel, Garfinkel and De Haro, as well as standard textbooks that cover the basics of network and probability theory, information cascades and how to code in python.

Syllabus

  • Emergence: Introduction and course content

Practicummateriaal

Software

Leerdoelen

  • The student is able to describe the concept of "emergence".
  • The student is able to analyse and study different models that exhibit emergent phenomena using mathematical methods and numerical simulation.
  • The student is able to identify the distinctive features of emergence in various examples.
  • The student is able to distinguish between the concepts of "emergence", "reduction" and related notions.
  • The student is able to solve simple nonlinear differential equations and apply elements of network theory, graph theory, probabilistic theory and Bayes rules.
  • The student is able to write an interdisciplinary essay that combines philosophical insights and mathematical modelling of a given case of emergent phenomena.

Onderwijsvormen

  • Hoorcollege
  • Werkcollege
  • Zelfstudie
  • Zelfstandig werken aan bijv. project/scriptie

During the lectures the students will be presented with notions and cases of emergence and reduction and how to think about them from a philosophical point of view. The students will also become acquainted with computer modelling and mathematical techniques to study emergent phenomena.

In the workcolleges the students will have the opportunity to discuss  concepts of emergence further, debate, inquire as well as practice exercise sets and modelling skills.

Self-study will allow the students to dive in depth into emergence by reading works by several scientists and philosophers who have different points of views on emergence, not always compatible.

In an interdisciplinary essay that combines philosophy with mathematics/simulation the students will have the opportunity to summarise their understanding of emergence and its many facets. 

Verdeling leeractiviteiten

Activiteit

Uren

Hoorcollege

26

Tentamen

6

Werkcollege

26

Zelfstudie

110

Totaal

168

(6 EC x 28 uur)

Aanwezigheid

Aanwezigheidseisen opleiding (OER-B):

  • 1. In geval van werkgroepbijeenkomsten is de student verplicht tenminste 7 van elke 8 werkgroepbijeenkomsten bij te wonen, tenzij anders aangegeven in de studiewijzer. Bij meer dan 8 werkgroepbijeenkomsten geldt dat de student steeds per (deel van) 8 bijeenkomsten maximaal 1 bijeenkomst mag missen. Indien de student minder dan het verplichte aantal bijeenkomsten heeft bijgewoond, kan het vak niet worden afgerond.
  • In geval van een practicum is de student verplicht ten minste 90% van de practicumbijeenkomsten bij te wonen, tenzij anders aangegeven in de studiewijzer. In geval de student minder dan 90% heeft bijgewoond dient het practicum opnieuw te worden gevolgd.

Aanvullende eisen voor dit vak:

Some basic knowledge in mathematical methods, natural/social sciences and programming is needed. However, the course aims at being self-contained. The course will be taught in English, as such good knowledge of English is required.

In particular, the student would benefit from taking the course on mathematical methods (first-year Beta-Gamma) and Keerpunten in de Natuurwetenschappen. 

Special Covid019 measures: We explicitly ask you not to come to campus for workgroups if you have any Covid-19 related symptoms (or you have to be in isolation etc.). In that case please notify your workgroup teacher and there will be an alternative for the workgroup attendance.  

Toetsing

Onderdeel en weging Details

Eindcijfer

60%

Tentamen 1

40%

Essay

There will be three exams evaluating the three parts of the course - each exam counts 20%, all exams a total of 60%.

An interdisciplinary essay of 2500 words (consisting of of both philosophical and mathematical/simulation elements) - 40% of the grade.

Toetsmatrijs (studentenversie)

Leerdoel: Toetsonderdeel 1: Toetsonderdeel 2:
#1. Exam Essay writing
#2. Exam Essay writing
#3. Exam Essay writing
#4. Exam Essay writing
#5. Exam Essay writing
#6.   Essay writing
     

Inzage toetsing

Via Canvas

Opdrachten

The exams are individual assignments.

The essay is a group assignment (groups of two).

Non-assessed assignments include the reading of relevant literature and solving exercise sheets.

Fraude en plagiaat

Dit vak hanteert de algemene 'Fraude- en plagiaatregeling' van de UvA. Hier wordt nauwkeurig op gecontroleerd. Bij verdenking van fraude of plagiaat wordt de examencommissie van de opleiding ingeschakeld. Zie de Fraude- en plagiaatregeling van de UvA: http://student.uva.nl

Weekplanning

Weeknummer Onderwerpen Studiestof Deadlines for assignments
1 Introduction to the course and basic notions of emergence, reduction as well as examples of emergent phenomena. Focus on history of emergence and social science. Essays by Anderson and Hodgson.  
2 Philosophical study of reductionism. Essay by Nagel.  
3 Philosophical study of anti-reductionism. Essay by Garfinkel.  
4 Philosophical study of Emergence. Essay by De Haro.  
5 Introduction to statistical physics. Entropy demystified by Arieh Ben-naim Exam.
6 Models and cellular automata Introduction to cellular automata by Schiff Submit essay topic.
7 Population dynamics

Mathematics of Epidemics on Networks: From Exact to Approximate Models by Kiss et al.

 
8 Break    
9 Networks Textbook on network theory by Newman.  
10 Emergence in social contexts   Exam.
11 Voting rules Deliberation, single-peakedness and the possibility of meaningful democracy, by Miller et al.  Submit essay abstract.
12 Segregation and consensus  Reaching consensus by De Groot.    
13 Holiday break    
14 Information cascades Infostorm by Hendricks et al.  
15 Emergence in the future All previous literature is relevant.  Exam. Send essay draft for feedback.

16

No class    

17

No class   Submit final essay.

Rooster

Het rooster van dit vak is in te zien op DataNose.

Vakevaluatie afgelopen jaar

Vanaf 2013-2014 hebben we ervoor gekozen om d.m.v. onderstaande tabel de studenten meer inzicht te geven in de kwaliteitszorg. Daarom nemen we een korte weergave van de studentenevaluatie op en de daaruit voortvloeiende acties ter verbetering van het vak.

Emergentie (EC) N 4 2020-2021
Sterke punten
  • Brede kijk op het onderwerp 
  • Leuke werkgroepdocenten
Suggesties ter verbetering
  • Meer aandacht aan onderwerpen buiten de Natuurkunde
Reactie docent:
  •  

Contactinformatie

Coördinator

  • dr. J. Armas

Docenten

  • dr. Sebastian De Haro Ollé
  • dr. Wout Merbis
  • Soroush Rafiee Rad
  • Simon Stuij
  • Khaled Tamimy BSc